Sidestepping the Nonsense of Non-living Texts

By Dr. Bhaswati Bhattacharya

Subjects that encompass knowledge that helps society and its members are considered disciplines in the best universities. However, those subjects that help people take care of their minds, and themselves and empower their inner abilities are considered unscholarly. Self-development is considered unteachable and unprofessional. These tools are relegated to self-help groups, and religious institutions, or sidelined as unacademic, as though self-help is indulgence.

If people develop themselves inside, so their minds can be strong from their core, why is that unscholarly?  The best businesses provide exactly this training to help their core employees outperform. But these core employees are selected for loyalty, likeness, and ability to further the business’ mission. They are otherwise unworthy. In some businesses, secrecy is renamed discretion; transparency is renamed need-to-know.

In the mainstream, understanding the mind has historically led to control of the mind and religious fanaticism. Witness any evangelism that does not teach its followers to think critically and independently.

So how then shall a person learn how to think, how to untie the knots in their minds and transform their obstacles and unhealthy reactions?

Perhaps Ayurveda is also suppressed because it interferes with the business of profiting from diseased people desperate for help. Yet, despite all these power and control issues, there are hundreds of vaidyas who are silently sidestepping the nonsense of ineffective teaching and incompetent bridges of outdated pedagogy, by learning in the proven ways of ancient traditions. They have learned to return to the things that worked for 1000s of years rather than jumping first into the latest and often unproven techniques.

Those who understand the true principles of Ayurveda can test them out in the world, gain confidence, and then validate their awareness by helping patient after patient, marveling at the predictive, preventive, and profound ways that shifting the doshas through the gunas and srotas work time after time. This is the test of a good vaidya. Vaidyas are difficult to find if you are using modern search strategies or credentials and awards to determine your decision.

The principles of Ayurveda are unnecessarily difficult for medical students in Ayurveda to learn because they have to unlearn the archaic knowledge in their outdated textbooks of basic mainstream biology, chemistry, and medicine.

For example, if we believe that the gut is separated where our physiology text teaches, we will never understand the larger function of items that are omitted from the text, such as the understanding of food entering the body. New research in physiology shows that misconceptions due to poor or uninformed techniques have led to omissions, but even their research is not incorporated into medical education promptly. If we learn anatomy as the textbooks profess, we cannot see the structure-function relationships that underlie the body parts. The texts are not living. However, yoga movement scientists who use living bodies to learn, such as Leslie Kaminoff, have shown that fascial layers around the muscles connect the upper limbs through the trunk to the lower limbs. We accelerate our pace by using our arms and breath. His team has discovered principles of movements never found in medical texts.

Another example is of surgeons who have found capillaries linking the lungs to the stomach since the growth of the fetus, but this is not given importance in mainstream clinical medicine. Ayurveda however relates the fire and residue in the storage part of the upper stomach with the phlegm in the lungs. Clinically it is exactly what a doctor finds on reading anatomy research not found in textbooks, but only if her mind is open. This understanding tells us to clean out the stomach with digestive herbs such as ginger and cumin, and drink hot water, to clear out the lungs and reduce fevers.

To condition the mind to learn beyond the obstacles set by education specialists who are not actually wisemen is one of the tests of becoming a good vaidya.

Dr. Bhaswati Bhattacharya is a Fulbright Specialist 2018‐2023 in Public Health and Clinical Asst. Professor of Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York. Email: [email protected], Website:

Images courtesy of (Image: Ekhart Yoga and Provided

Share this post